Human Rights and Judicial Review in Australia and Canada: The Newest Despotism?

Erscheinungsjahr 2019
ISBN: 978-1-5099-3310-5
Verlag: HART PUB

Buch, Englisch, 320 Seiten, Paperback, Format (B × H): 169 mm x 244 mm, Gewicht: 517 g

Reihe: Hart Studies in Comparative Pu

It is commonly asserted that bills of rights have had a 'righting' effect on the principles of judicial review of administrative action and have been a key driver of the modern expansion in judicial oversight of the executive arm of government. A number of commentators have pointed to Australian administrative law as evidence for this 'righting' hypothesis. They have suggested that the fact that Australia is an outlier among common law jurisdictions in having neither a statutory nor a constitutional framework to expressly protect human rights explains why Australia alone continues to take an apparently 'formalist', 'legalist' and 'conservative' approach to administrative law. Other commentators and judges, including a number in Canada, have argued the opposite: that bills of rights have the effect of stifling the development of the common law. However, for the most part, all these claims remain just that - there has been limited detailed analysis of the issue, and no detailed comparative analysis of the veracity of the claims. This book analyses in detail the interaction between administrative and human rights law in Australia and Canada, arguing that both jurisdictions have reached remarkably similar positions regarding the balance between judicial and executive power, and between broader fundamental principles including the rule of law, parliamentary sovereignty and the separation of powers. It will provide valuable reading for all those researching judicial review and human rights.

Autoren/Hrsg.

Boughey, Janina

Fachgebiete

• Rechtswissenschaften Ausländisches Recht Common Law (UK, USA, Australien u.a.)
• Rechtswissenschaften Recht, Rechtswissenschaft Allgemein Rechtsvergleichung
• Rechtswissenschaften Internationales Recht und Europarecht Internationales Recht Internationale Menschen- und Minderheitenrechte, Kinderrechte
• Sozialwissenschaften Politikwissenschaft Politische Kultur Menschenrechte, Bürgerrechte

Inhaltsverzeichnis

1. Introduction
I. The 'Righting' of Administrative Law?
II. This Book's Contribution
III. A Note on Methodology
IV. The Scope of this Book
V. The Structure of this Book

Part I: Constitutional and Statutory Frameworks
2. The Framework for Judicial Review of Administrative Action in Australia
I. Australia's Constitution
II. The Constitutional Status of Judicial Review
III. Statutory Judicial Review Frameworks
IV. Australia's Human Rights Framework
V. Conclusions
3. The Framework for Judicial Review of Administrative Action in Canada
I. Canada's Constitution
II. The Constitutional Status of Judicial Review
III. Privative Clauses and the Standard of Review
IV. Statutory Judicial Review Frameworks
V. Canada's Human Rights Framework
VI. Conclusions

Part II: The Effects of Canada's Rights Framework on Judicial Review
4. Procedural Fairness
I. Overview of Rights to Fairness
II. The Scope of the Common Law Duty to Afford Procedural Fairness
III. The Content of Fairness
IV. The Rationales for Fairness
V. Litigants' Use of Fairness
VI. Entrenchment of Procedural Fairness
VII. Conclusions
5. Controlling Discretion
I. A Brief History of Judicial Attitudes Towards Discretion
II. Controlling Discretion in Australia
III. Controlling Discretion in Canada
IV. Human Rights Controls on Discretion
V. Conclusions
6. Intensity of Review
I. Intensity Under the Classic Model
II. Intensity of Review in Australia
III. Intensity of Review in Canada
IV. Conclusions
7. Conclusions

Über Autor(innen)

Boughey, Janina
Janina Boughey is Senior Lecturer at the University of New South Wales Faculty of Law. Janina's research focusses on the interaction between human rights and judicial review of administrative action, comparative administrative law, statutory interpretation, and the nature and limits of the constitutional powers of the judiciary and legislature to hold the executive to account. Janina has published widely on these topics, including a monograph, Human Rights and Judicial Review in Australia and Canada: The Newest Despotism? (Hart Publishing, 2017).

Janina Boughey is a Lecturer in Public Law at Monash University.